CIS 601 Spring 2008

Homework 4: Review paper

Please write a review of the paper

Rotation Invariant Shape Context

Think you are a reviewer for a journal at the level of 'Patter Recognition Letters', which is a 'reputable' journal (in a ranking of 'premium - leading - reputable - others - not recommended'). Write your review along the following lines:

What's the paper's content ?

What's the main contribution ?

Is the paper well motivated, i.e. are there sound justifications for the approach ?

Is the paper technically sound?

Are the references sufficient ?

Is the paper readable ?

Are the experiments and results convincing?

Would you suggest to publish the paper? (ranking: accept as is, major revision, minor revision, reject)

Send your review to me (i expect 1-2 pages, word doc), not to Pattern Recognition Letters.
Enjoy! Due Date: March 26, 2008.